Best Rewards Card: The Starwood Preferred Guest® Credit Card from American Express

By Jason Steele. Last updated 16 July 2014. 10 comments

This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. Please visit our Advertising Policy for more details.

Amex

If you ever run into me at a social gathering, don’t get me started taking about credit cards because I might never stop. After a few minutes speaking about some of the great reward credit cards available, I am often interrupted by a single question — “Which one is the best?” I have participated in this conversation so often that I now just blurt out “Starwood” before you can complete your sentence. (See also: The Best Travel Rewards Cards)

Why the Starwood Preferred Guest Credit Card?

Since I learned how to use credit card rewards to travel the world, the Starwood Preferred Guest® Credit Card from American Express has become my favorite product, hands down. For each dollar I spend with this card, I earn one point in Starwood Hotel’s Preferred Guest program. Starwood is the parent company of several different hotel chains, including Sheraton, Westin, and Le Meridian. Once points are earned, members have nearly endless options to redeem them for free hotel nights, frequent flier miles, or other valuable awards. Of course, there are several other credit cards that offer hotel points, and many of those programs appear to have similar redemption options. But compared to its competitors, Starwood points offer unsurpassed value and flexibility. In fact, each Starpoint is worth far more than any airline mile or credit card reward point, let alone other points from competing hotel chains.

Generally speaking, for each dollar I spend using this card, I'm getting roughly 3 to 5 cents worth of free hotel stays or airfare back from the Starwood network. Other networks generally fall far short of this, providing me only with 1.5 cents back. Of course the 3 to 5 cents number is highly variable, and may go up or down depending on whether you are traveling during peak season (when you might get back more bang for your buck) or during off-peak season (when you might get back get less).

Using Starpoints for Free Nights at Hotels

Free night awards at Starwood hotels begin at a mere 2,000 points for a weekend stay. Although award nights at higher-end properties can cost as many as 35,000 points, Starwood has many luxury properties where an award night can be redeemed for 10,000 points or less. For example, my family recently stayed three nights at the Sheraton Four Points in Milan Italy for 10,000 points per night. We also have a three night reservation at a Sheraton Suites in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida that cost a total of 10,000 Starpoints. In contrast, a single award night with the Marriott rewards program starts at 7,500 points and goes up quickly from there. Furthermore, Starwood imposes no blackout dates or capacity restrictions on its hotel awards. If they have a room sale, you can instantly redeem your points for an award stay. Finally, when you redeem a four night stay with your Starpoints, the fifth night is free.

Transferring Starpoints to Airline Miles

I have met people who have redeemed hundreds of thousands of Starpoints without making a single reservation for an award night. These are travelers who earn Starpoints only because they can transfer them to miles in frequent flier programs. Award travel aficionados like me have discovered that Starpoints can be redeemed for miles in the frequent flier programs of over 30 different airlines plus Amtrak Guest Rewards points. When you realize that most of those airlines allow you to use their miles to book award flights with at least a dozen different partner carriers, you start to understand how this one credit card is the gateway to a staggering array of award travel opportunities. I have redeemed Starpoints for miles with carriers that I have never flown, which I used for award flights on their partner airlines that I had yet to travel on. I can also use a few thousand Starpoints to top off my various frequent flier accounts when I don’t quite have enough miles for the award I need.

If this flexibility wasn’t enough, mileage transfers also offer superior value. Starpoints are usually redeemed for miles at a 1:1 ratio, but when you redeem 20,000 Starpoints at once, you get a 5,000 point bonus. So in most cases, these bonuses allow you to earn more miles per dollar spent by using your Starwood card than you could by using that airline’s own co-branded product. In contrast, the Priority Club Rewards program run by the Intercontinental Hotels Group (the parent company of Holiday Inn and others), allows you to transfer points to a dozen different airlines, but requires you to redeem 10,000 points to earn 2,000 miles.

Other Benefits of This Card

When cardholders make any purchase at a Starwood property, they will earn a minimum of four points per dollar spent. Additionally, those who spend $30,000 in a calendar year will be upgraded to the Gold level in the Starwood Preferred Guest program. With this status, card members will earn five points per dollar spent at Starwood hotels while enjoying benefits such as room upgrades and late checkout privileges. Finally, award nights and mileage transfers are just two of a dozen different redemption options that include merchandise awards, charitable contributions, or the direct booking of flights. Having considered each of these other options, I have always found award nights and mileage transfers represent the most valuable utilization of my Starpoints.

The Downsides of the Starwood Card

For all my enthusiasm, I still realize that no credit card is perfect. For starters, those who carry a balance should not be trying to earn rewards with any card, let alone this card that does not offer competitive interest rates. When you don’t pay your balance in full, you will accrue interest at 15.24% - 19.24% variable. Additionally, American Express cards are not accepted everywhere, so I always carry a Visa or MasterCard as well. Despite using this card to earn award travel to other countries, I never use it outside the United States. That is because all charges processed outside of the United States will incur American Express’s onerous Foreign Transaction Fee of 2.7%. There is also an annual fee of $65, which is waived the first year. Finally, this card is a terrible way to earn United Airlines miles. Due to United’s close relationship with Chase, though which it offers its own co-branded cards, Starwood and American Express are only able to offer a single MileagePlus mile for every two Starpoints redeemed.

The Best Rewards Credit Card

If you are an experienced collector of points and miles, or if you are just starting your quest for award travel, you might as well just sign up for this card now. That way, you will earn fantastic awards, while I can feel free to talk about something else the next time we meet.

To the Credit Card Guide

Editorial Note: Any opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the author’s alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any card issuer.

Tagged: Credit Cards, Travel
4.2
Average: 4.2 (5 votes)
Your rating: None
ShareThis

comments

10 discussions

Add New Comment

CAPTCHA
This test helps prevent automated spam submissions.
Guest's picture
YoBucko

The Starwoods card is definitely a good choice. The only issue I had with it was that it didn't automatically link up to my American Express Starwoods card when I got it originally, so I didn't reap any of the benefits. Any recommendations for others on making sure you get the full benefits of the card?

Guest's picture
jkwondo

The flexibility of the card is somewhat in doubt. You must constantly try to find the hotels that happen to cost the least points, and to use on a flight ticket you have to transfer points to various different airlines and find the ones with seats available etc. If you want a hassle free experience, why not sign up for the Fidelity Retirement Rewards card and earn 2% CASH on everything, rather than a variable 3-5% that requires hours and hours of legwork to get the job done.

If you are at a cocktail party and people want to cut though the BS to hear the single best card, it seems unlikely that they would put up with the BS to maximize their return on points with a card like Starwoods as the point aficionados do.

Guest's picture
Roger

I agree that the Starwood Card is a great choice and definitely the card I use for my everyday spend needs. In terms of redemption, I would say it takes a small amount of time to figure out the cents/point you're realizing on various hotel choices, but in the end, I think the small amount of time you put in is worth it to maximize the value of your points. And when you're able to realize between 2-7 cents/point with the Starwood Card, I don't think that's a bad investment at all.

Guest's picture
Hazelvue

I don't understand how Mr. Steele is able to use the Starwood Preferred card to book hotels outside the US and not pay the 2.7% transaction fee he mentioned for foreign purchases? Does he use the starwood card to make the reservation at a foreign hotel using points and then a different card to pay the bill when he is actually at the foreign hotel?
Thanks,
Hazelvue

Guest's picture
Roger

Hazelvue, I believe what he is saying is that he uses the Starwood Card in the US to earn points to be able to redeem at Starwood hotels abroad. If he is using all points to pay for a hotel room abroad, it wouldn't be necessary to use your Starwood Card, since you wouldn't be responsible for any charges (and hence, no foreign transaction fees).

Guest's picture
Will

Is it possible to redeem these points for cash or gift cards at all?

Guest's picture

You can redeem points for gift cards from select merchants, but I don't think you can redeem points for cash. With that said, I think the best use of Starwood points is cashing in for hotels.

Guest's picture
alex

Is it possible to use the card and not sign up for rewards? I feel like I don't get that many points...

Guest's picture
Stephen

This card charges foreign transaction fees which add up significantly if you travel outside of the USA. Even worse, if you stay at a Starwood hotel overseas they often charge in local currency and won’t let you charge in dollars which means you pay the transaction fees 1-3% and that offsets any points benefits of this card.

Guest's picture
Guest

I am perplexed about this when booking hotels and paying bills internationally with Starwood American Express card... Isn't this what it's all about? Traveling and being able to pay was discarded turning points and not be charged an international fee. . .
I use my cards a lot for domestic purchases and have not travelled outside the US as of yet. Howeverwould like to see a change and not have fees for international travel or purchases.