Seafood on the Cheap

by Myscha Theriault on 4 January 2009 17 comments

Looking in incorporate more seafood into your diet? Not wanting to sell your left kidney to do it? Following are strategies, recipes, suggestions and resources to celebrate the sea affordably.

Shopping Strategies:

  • Frozen.   I'll be the first to admit that certain types of fish fillets just don't survive the flash freezing process with their taste intact. But as far as shrimp, scallops and mixed seafood go, I find them still more than workable with regards to flavor stability.
  • Hit the Docks.   Not everyone lives next to a place where you can snag the fishermen as they land back home for the day. But if you do, this can be a stellar way to snag great fresh fish on the cheap. Being in the know certainly helps, so I have some feelers in to a top chef or two for a follow up article on how to shop smart when it comes to fresh seafood. (Stay tuned.)
  • Canned.   This won't work for every type of fish, and certainly not for every recipe. However, there are numerous ways to use canned salmon, clams, oysters, caviar and mussels that save money and still provide style.
  • Be Domestic.   I'm sure you're expecting me to launch into a home cooking sermon here, and I'll certainly touch on that in a bit. But that's not the strategy I'm talking about here. Since I mentioned caviar above, I'll use that as an example. Not necessarily needing the finest imported variety can save you hundreds of dollars per jar. Stretch it out as an accent on canapes for even greater savings.
  • Bulk and Loss Leader Sales.   Certain types of seafood go on sale from time to time in accordance with certain holidays and events. While it's certainly good to take advantage of those opportunities when they come along, if you live near a Costco you can get great prices on certain types of fresh seafood on a fairly frequent basis. How? They have fresh seafood for sale in bulk every other weekend. While some of the prices were still way higher than I wanted to pay, there were certain types of crab for under six bucks a pound and both mussels and Rhode Island clams were in the two dollar a pound range.

Poached eggs and smoked salmon by Allerina & Glen MacLarty

Resources and Suggestions:

  • SoupBase.Com.   This web site offers fantastic professional base flavorings for the home chef at prices way more affordable than buying the stock yourself, if you can even find it in a store near you. While they have loads of flavoring and seasoning options for all sorts of food, for the purposes of this article I contacted them regarding a product test of their standard seafood and clam bases. They were happy to send along a sample of each, as well as a can of their cocktail clams (Delish!). In order to get this article out as soon as possible, I put the pedal to the mettle and test drove both bases this weekend. Yesterday, it was the seafood base in both a newburg sauce and a batch of surimi and cucumber canapes. The results? Stellar. Today, it was the clam base's turn. To focus completely on the flavor factor, I did a simple assembly cooking batch of red clam sauce and set some aside in the crock pot to simmer away for tonight's dinner. So far, I'm noticing a difference there as well. I think the important thing to remember is that you won't be changing your overall recipe that much. You'll simply be able to add that “extra something” you would otherwise only be able to find in a restaurant. Definitely a two thumbs up product.
  • Buy the Trim.   This one applies to smoked salmon. So far, the only company I've seen offer this is Duck Trap River. Here's the deal: By purchasing the packaged trim for seven to nine dollars a pound instead of the regular smoked salmon packs for twenty-five to thirty-seven dollars a pound, you'll get all the flavor and none of the high priced hangover. There is absolutely no difference in flavor or quality that I've seen. In fact, the only difference I've seen at all is that with the packages of trim, you will notice a few slightly darker patches here and there. It's simply the end portion of the fish. Big deal. Since these also tend to be on the ends of the pieces of smoked salmon, they are easily sliced off if they bother you. But honestly, there are very few of them, and they are still usable in a chowder or smoked salmon Alfredo if placing those few little tidbits on top of a canape doesn't float your boat. The trim packs usually hang just below the regular packages of smoked salmon in the refrigerated case next to the seafood section of the meat department.
  • Practice Fish Yoga.   Basically, this is very similar to my recent suggestions on stretching meat money. Think shrimp pad Thai, smoked salmon canapes, lobster bisque or mussels and mushrooms with linguini in white wine sauce. These are all great ways to feed 4-8 people at a home dinner party for less than the cost of a decent dinner for two at a moderately priced restaurant.

Scallop salad by Allerina & Glen MacLarty

Recipe Ideas:

Rather than list out every seafood recipe known to man and leave you to implement the various strategies and suggestions above where you happen to spot an opportunity, I'll be using this category to provide ideas for the more affordable types of seafood you might not immediately consider incorporating.

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Mixed Seafood.   This is the stuff you can usually find frozen at the grocery stores for five bucks a bag, or in the super giant bags at Sam's Club for around eleven dollars. I've seen it used with a fair amount of flair in newburg, paella, and in this slamming dinner soup from El Salvador: Ingredients: 1 bag of mixed seafood, 1 can of diced tomatoes (seasoned is nice), 1 can of baby clams,2 cups of broth (fish or even chicken), 1 cup of white wine, ½ a chopped onion, olive oil, 1 diced green pepper, cilantro and parsley to taste, a flexible amount of water depending on the thickness you desire. Fry all ingredientsexcept seafood and liquids in olive oil to release flavor. Add seafood mix, broth and water and simmer until the flavors have suitably blended. Serve with crusty bread and whipped garlic butter if desired.
  • Haddock.   A basic fish that many people lean on when trying to incorporate more seafood into home menus. A few recipes that caught my attention? Haddock with bacon and onions, haddock ravioli, this recipe for creamy haddock pie, and this collection of haddock recipes featuring ideas for both home spun and more exotic entrees.
  • Frozen Shrimp.   These fall into two categories. First, the frozen miniature salad shrimp, suitable for bisque, spring rolls, shrimp toast or paired with cocktail sauce over cream cheese for a basic party spread. Second, the slightly larger frozen shrimp that you can buy either raw or pre-cooked. The simplest way we enjoy these is stir fried with snow peas over rice. Getting a good sale or the four dollar a pound frozen ones at Aldi's, you can also whip DIY versions of shrimp primavera, lo mein, Alfredo, shrimp cocktail, kabobs or any other favored restaurant entrée with a reasonable amount of flair and quality.
  • Canned Clams.   In addition to a basic red clam pasta sauce, the large cans of these you can buy in bulk as a double pack at the warehouse store can also be used in dips, creamy white clam sauces or a rustic clam and corn chowder
  • Scallops.   The most affordable strategy I've found for buying these is to go frozen, and choose bay scallops over the larger ones. I can usually get them for under four dollars a pound this way, which is less expensive than both shrimp and imitation crab meat, and I have absolutely no prep work to do with them. They make a great seafood linguini, Thai noodles and basic Asian stir fry.  They are also quite elegant in a scallop and artichoke risotto, over pasta in a cream sauce with sun dried tomatoes, or with lemon and dill served with rice.

This is seafood on the cheap in as much of a nutshell as I can provide it, folks. Also of note is surimi (imitation crab meat) which has so many yummy ways to use it, that I'll be doing a completely separate article, coming soon. Got another great seafood tip that's doable on a budget? Don't forget to sound off.

 

3.5
Average: 3.5 (2 votes)
Your rating: None
ShareThis
ADVERTISEMENT

comments

17 discussions

Add New Comment

CAPTCHA
This test helps prevent automated spam submissions.
Andrea Karim's picture

I love those cheap little shrimp! I had never really eaten them outside of the occasional seafood salad, but they make an awesome seafood filler for seafood manicotti. They are so sweet, and I love that you don't have to clean them.

My mother buys these big bags of HUGE frozen scallops at Costco. I'm sure they aren't cheap, but I can vouch for the fact that they last a long time and make a great chowder.

Myscha Theriault's picture

Oh man, Andrea!!!! That's a great idea for filling the pasta on the cheap. I wonder how many things you can do with the salad shrimp if you really put your mind to it? I think I smell a post coming on. For now though, I'm busy collating ideas for imitation crab meat.

Guest's picture
4 Jan. 2009 | 3:41 PM Elizabeth

Oh! I'm glad I came across this article. I've been on the look out for inexpensive sea food ideas. The frozen scallop in Asian stir fry sounds delicious.

One thing I'd like to add is to buy raw shrimp to save money, but get the de-veined ones (they're easier to work with if you're not an expert).

Myscha, one of my parents' favourite tricks with imitation crab meat is open faced sandwiches. They mix the meat with mayo, celery and onion (to make it go further, if needed), then spread it on whole grain bread and top with a little shredded cheese. Then pop it under the broiler to melt.

Rats. Now I'm getting hungry.

Myscha Theriault's picture

Thanks for the cheesy crab toast idea. Sounds yummy. Good luck with the Asian stirfry.

Guest's picture

Hi Myscha - love the post & I agree that seafood can be tricky on the cheap. Just a note on the frozen shrimp - most are farm raised in Asia & South America, where their aren't too many health guidelines intact, so sanitation is an issue.
I've been super happy with Prince Edward Island mussels that I can pick up at Costco - super tasty and they are raised in a regulated & sustainable way.

Guest's picture

I'm not a big fan of seafood, but maybe that's because I've lived in the Arizona desert all my life. I know I prefer fresh picked vegetables from my garden, and anything from the store is nowhere near as good, so I assume seafood is the same. My youngest son is turning out to be quite the seafood fan and complains that his father and I didn't introduce it to him when he was growing up. He is an aspiring chef - I am going to send him the link to this post, I am sure he'll find the post very helpful and I like the frugal nature of it!

Andrea Karim's picture

I can't for the life of me get into imitation crab (or as we call it, "crab with a k-"... krab). I know that regular crab is quite sweet, but imitation crab is sweet to the point where I can't stand it, even if it is mixed in with other seafood. I wish I liked it, because it's such a cheap alternative, and the texture is wonderful... I just can't get over the flavor. I used to have a boyfriend who would eat the stuff straight out of the package, too, which might have contributed to our break-up. :)

I'm not sure if you've seen this before, Myscha, but you can actually make your own lox if you buy a fresh half of a salmon - just Google 'gravlax recipe' and you'll get tons of options. You can cure it in your fridge using the most basic ingredients. I've never tried it, but I know people who do it all the time with really good results.

Here are a few example recipes:

Lox and bagels is a favorite in our house, and smoked salmon adds so much depth to chowders, crab cakes, and pasta. Oh, and I find that Coscto and Trader Joe's vacillate between who has the cheapest canned crab, but you can generally find a pound of it for about $10 - makes for some amazing dinners at my house.

Guest's picture

Just a caution note: In some grocery stores (hopefully not the pricey, high-quality ones), the pre-cooked shrimp in the seafood case is usually just frozen shrimp that they've defrosted. I had an employee of the seafood case tell me that one time, and it really threw me off.

I like the tip of buying uncooked, devained shrimp. I'd bet you could buy them on sale in a larger quantity, then just freeze them yourself and they last a long time.

Also, does anyone have a B.J.'s in their town? They're like Costco, but I've found their quality of food is miles better, and better priced.

Guest's picture

I just went to a B.J.'s in Delaware with my mom this past weekend. We kept noticing the prices weren't good. We kept saying "It's cheaper at Walmart." Maybe it was happened to be true for the things we were interested in, but we said it many times.

Guest's picture
4 Jan. 2009 | 8:47 PM Jocelyn

I love ideas for being frugal that still have flare! Recently I have found that Dollar Tree stores have had hidden gems in their small freezer sections, bags of frozen shrimp and scallops (small yes, but for a dollar, why not). I once found brie, yes brie cheese in Dollar Tree of what I thought was about average quality, and I consider myself a huge fan of cheese and always on the lookout for a way to avoid paying top dollar for those fancy cheeses.
Thanks for the ideas!

Myscha Theriault's picture

Thanks for all the positive comments, guys. And Andrea, I have never heard of lox but those links look awesome! Thanks for sharing them.

Guest's picture

I am reading a Spanish cookbook on how to make paella. They suggest using snails from the garden, if you don't use pesticides! We have a lot of snails...

I am also looking into learning how to harvest razor clams and other seafood, since I live near the coast. I have yet to find anyone who wants to go with me.

Another tip is to wait until a certain type of fish goes on sale whole. Around here it is salmon or halibut. If you buy the whole fish, a good market will cut it up for you or filet it, similar to buying a quarter or half a beef. I have a vacuum sealer so I can freeze it without freezer burn.

I grew up inland and we lived without most seafood. It was a Christmas Eve treat.

Guest's picture
5 Jan. 2009 | 1:19 PM Margaret

You've convinced me to try the smoked salmon trimmings. I pass them all the time while at the shop, but I've never been brave enough to try them (the dark bits and the fact that they're the store's economy brand scared me off). These are some great ideas!

And as the the home grown snails, Gordon Ramsay did a bit about catching and cooking snails from your garden, good tips for those who are interested: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BaOZpKtwBpM

Myscha Theriault's picture

You know what else is cool about the packs of trim is that they come in an actual one pound package. The non-trim packs aren't even a full pound.

Thanks for the snails link. Are they the same snails as in escargot?

 

Guest's picture
6 Jan. 2009 | 2:37 PM Jocelyn

I'm not a big fan of seafood, but maybe that's because I've lived in the proactive Arizona desert all my life. I know I prefer fresh picked vegetables from my garden, and anything from the store is nowhere near as good, so I assume seafood is the same.

Guest's picture
6 Jan. 2009 | 4:19 PM Johanna B

Find a good cookbook with recipes from south Louisiana - creole, cajun, etc. and you'll find tons of recipes using small amounts of seafood to make wonderful tasty dishes. I recommend River Road Recipes, the first one.

Tisha Tolar's picture

I love seafood but I am not a fan of fishy tasting fish. We buy frozen tilapia, which is not expensive - and season it with lemon pepper. Pop it in the oven and serve with flavored rice. Even my 6 year old loves it. We add a little lemon juice before eating.

We also buy frozen shrimp and add it to Pasta Roni's vermicelli and olive oil. We sprinkle parmesean cheese and I add a little lemon juice to this too. Tastes better than at a restaurant for about $6 that feeds 3 people.