7 Reasons Your E-mail Pitches Are Failing

Photo: archives

You've got a great product or service that you know people would love if you could just get the word out. And what better way to spread the word than via an email blast? It's cost effective. It reaches everybody. You could probably write it yourself. But in this spam-filled digital age, you need to make sure your message isn't tossed out with the rest of the trash.

If you're finding that you're getting zero love back from your email pitches, it's probably not your service or product (because it's awesome, right?). It's more likely your delivery. As a small business owner myself, I get hundreds of solicitations from other business owners asking me to "check out this service." Unfortunately, I often end up clicking the "delete" (or worse, the "report spam") button, even though I know there must be a few gems in there.

These are the seven most common mistakes I see from those trying to reach out.

You are sending it to the wrong person.

It should be obvious, but you must do your research before you send your pitch. Just because an email is easy to send, doesn't mean you shouldn't take the time to do it right. Find the right person and tailor your message to that person's needs.

An email sent to webmaster@sitename.com will most likely end up in the black hole of emails. What did it matter that it took you very little time to send it? You've still wasted your time. If your pitches aren't landing in the right person's mailbox, then your email won't be useful, period, no matter how well written it is.

You are not offering a clear benefit.

The most annoying email that I get goes something like, "Please check out my website and let me know what you think!" Who are you and why should I spend my time doing you a favor? Entice me. Give me a reason why you're going to make my life better (but do it quickly and concisely). Tell me why your product is groundbreaking and offer me a sneak peak or free trial. And more importantly, make me like you enough that I would even want to "check out" what you have to offer.

You are writing too much.

No one is going to take the time to read through a long email from someone she doesn't know. Introduce yourself (briefly) and get to the point. Be specific and clear. Break down your message to its key elements — think "elevator pitch." You only have a small window of time to catch someone's interest. There are hundreds of other emails waiting in line.

You are not asking for a specific action.

If you've gone through the process of explaining your company, but have left no specific call to action, it's likely that you won't get any response, even if the recipient is interested. What are the next steps? Sign up for an account online? Arrange a meeting? Don't expect the other person to take the initiative. Tell them what they should do next.

You are being mysterious.

This is another type of email that I never respond to: "I have an exciting opportunity for you. Please call me to discuss it further." It tells me that you've got nothing interesting to offer me, and worse, that you've got no respect for my time. The Mr. Vague approach won't pique anyone's interest and it won't inspire follow up. If you want me to be interested, be direct and tell me what you're offering.

You are being too pushy.

It's fine to follow up, but you aren't entitled to a response. If you haven't gotten a response, you can assume that the other party isn't interested. Never send out a follow up message that simply says, "I haven't heard back from you about the message I sent last week. Please respond as soon as you can." Instead, try a different tactic. Look at your last email and see if you could frame your message better. Was it too long? Did you not include a strong benefit? Try again with a shorter, smarter pitch. But stop after two attempts. You can try sending it to another person in that organization, but at some point you have to let it go.

You are expecting too much.

Telling someone that you did something for them ("I linked to you in my blogroll!") and then asking for the same in return is simply bad form. If you are interested in a true partnership, the relationship has to be mutually beneficial and the terms agreed upon up front. You can send a note that explains that because you are a big fan of the site, you've added it to your blogroll, but don't expect anything in return (except a warm thanks).

Sending out a "cold email" may not be as difficult as cold calling on the phone, but it's just as important to get the pitch right. Otherwise you're wasting everyone's time.

No votes yet
Your rating: None

Disclaimer: The links and mentions on this site may be affiliate links. But they do not affect the actual opinions and recommendations of the authors.

Wise Bread is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

Guest's picture

Great article! Some emails are indeed ignored or they just go to spam/trash because it sounds pushy. Pitches should be in the perfect timing. Pitches should sound like a "need" instead of a want. Your product should be the "solution to the customers' problem" rather than another addition to their problem (expense).

Guest's picture

Hi Lynn,

You bring up great points on why email pitches fail or are failing. I too delete or mark as spam most emails that I suspect as advertisement. I guess I would not be a prime candidate to target regardless of the advertisement. Additionally, I believe in today's Internet environment riddled with malicious threats such as spyware, rootlets, trojans and hijacking software I am always suspicious and certainly apprehensive to ever open emails from anyone I do not know … how can email marketers contend with such a reputation of growing dangers of malware and such?