The 5 Best Makeup Removers


When you’re experimenting with glitter makeup or waterproof mascara, you need the best remover to completely remove all traces of makeup with no irritation. Whether you have a full face of makeup on, or just like to apply a quick coat of mascara every morning, how you remove your makeup is just as important as how you apply it. That’s because going to bed with any makeup still on your face can result in clogged pores, acne, blackheads, and irritated skin.

What Is Makeup Remover?

Makeup remover is a cosmetic item that can help effortlessly remove makeup. It can be used before cleansing the skin to remove stubborn makeup, like waterproof mascara. It can also be used to remove makeup spills from the floor and any hard surfaces.

Top 5 Makeup Removers

Neutrogena Cleansing Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

Neutrogena Cleansing Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover can remove even the most stubborn makeup, like waterproof mascara. The dermatologist-developed, ophthalmologist-tested remover is safe for contact lens wearers and won’t irritate even the most sensitive skin. The oil-free, fragrance-free remover has been clinically proven to naturally remove makeup while moisturizing the skin around the eyes.

Your skin will feel clean and fresh thanks to the aloe and cucumber extracts. It is 97% naturally derived and leaves no greasy residue behind. The affordable makeup remover is gentle and refreshing, yet very effective, so you won’t need to pull or tug on the eye to remove your makeup. The dual-action formula activates when the solution is shaken up.

This is one of Amazon’s bestselling makeup removers and one of the “most wished for” items on Amazon. It is also a Total Beauty top-rated beauty product. Good Housekeeping selected it as the best remover for waterproof makeup, as well as a top performer compared to all other waterproof eye makeup removers. It also received top marks from the Good Housekeeping testing lab, as well as from beauty mavens. If you prefer makeup remover wipes, try the bestselling Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes.

Currently $6.15 on Amazon

Almay Oil-Free Gentle Eye Makeup Remover Pads

Almay Oil-Free Gentle Eye Makeup Remover Pads are small, but powerful. The convenient pads will power through stubborn makeup, while soothing the delicate skin around the eyes. They will leave your lashes soft and conditioned, while the surrounding skin will feel smooth and hydrated. The oil-free pads won’t irritate even sensitive eyes and won’t leave a greasy residue behind. The fragrance-free formula is gentle and refreshing thanks to a special botanical blend of aloe vera, cucumber, and green tea. The hypoallergenic, ophthalmologist-tested pads are ideal for contact lens wearers. They are convenient, affordable, and can be used as-is, so you won’t need a cotton ball. With 120 pads, you will be able to use as many as needed to remove all makeup, but most reviewers found that one pad is enough for each eye.

These pads are one of Amazon’s bestselling makeup removers. They are also backed by four Allure Best of Beauty Awards and recommended by Good Housekeeping. They are also a Total Beauty top-rated beauty product. Almay is the #1 eye makeup remover brand in the country, so if you’re looking for something to fix small smudges, try the highly rated Almay Oil-Free Makeup Eraser Sticks.

Currently $7.99 on Amazon

Simple Cleansing Water, Micellar

The Simple Micellar Cleansing Water looks and feels like water, but is so much more than simple water. The refreshing micellar water is made with gentle cleansers and beneficial ingredients, like vitamins B3 and C, which can improve the condition of your skin. The fragrance-free makeup remover is made of triple-purified water to help minimize potential particles or contaminants that can irritate the skin. The gentle cleansing water has no harsh chemicals, perfumes, or dyes, so it is ideal even for the most sensitive skin. While the dermatologist-tested pure cleansing water is designed for sensitive skin, it actually works well on all skin types. It will refresh and instantly boost skin hydration by 90%, so your skin will feel fresh, revitalized, soft, and smooth.

It will completely remove makeup, dirt, and oil from the skin, without drying it out or leaving any greasy residue behind. It will thoroughly cleanse and tone the face, unclog pores, and completely remove any trace of makeup. To use, simply saturate a cotton pad and wipe it around the face and closed eyes. You won’t even need to rinse after.

This is commonly compared to the Bioderma Micellar Water and can stand up to the expensive competitor. This is the 2015 Allure Best of Beauty Award Winner. It is also the common choice among professional makeup artists and beauty editors. If you prefer makeup remover wipes, try the bestselling Simple Make-Up Micellar Remover Wipes.

Currently $5.37 on Amazon

Mary Kay Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

When compared to other high-end makeup removers, the Mary Kay Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover often comes out on top because it most effectively and effortlessly dissolves any trace of makeup. The hypoallergenic, non-comedogenic, ophthalmologist-tested, oil-free makeup remover is gentle enough for contact lens wearers. It is also clinically tested for skin irritancy and allergy to ensure it is ideal for anyone with sensitive eyes. The fragrance-free formula works well even on stubborn waterproof makeup. It is gentle and refreshing, yet very effective, so you won’t need to pull or tug on the eye to remove your makeup. Instead of drying out the skin like some makeup removers can, it will actually leave your skin feeling smooth and moisturized afterwards.

It is one of Amazon’s bestselling makeup removers and has stellar reviews online. It is a 2015 Total Beauty Readers’ Choice Award Winner and a Total Beauty top-rated beauty product.

Currently $15.50 on Amazon

Makeup Remover Cloth and Makeup Brush Cleaner

This Makeup Remover Cloth and Makeup Brush Cleaner duo is natural, easy to use, and is a #1 new release in facial cleansing cloths on Amazon for a reason. This two pack of colorful facial cleansing cloths is a great Makeup Eraser dupe. The all-natural cloth works to remove all makeup, including stubborn eye makeup. The cloths are chemical free and incredibly soft, so they won’t harm even sensitive skin.

All you need to do is add water and then use the cloth to remove makeup and deep clean your skin. Simply wipe it across your skin like a washcloth and it will remove makeup like an eraser. It is machine washable, so it can be used again and again, which offers an environmentally friendly option. This will save you money in no time as you won’t need to deal with expensive disposable makeup remover wipes, oils, pads, towelettes, or cleansers. The double-sided cloth is oil-free and has no lotions, chemicals, or cream.

Best of all, this comes with a makeup brush cleanser (or BrushEgg dupe), which is one of our favorite makeup brush cleaners. Using the makeup remover cloth and makeup brush cleaner together will ensure that you enjoy clean, clear skin after every makeup application.

There are countless videos and reviews written about these types of erasers and mostly everyone seems to have great results. Similar makeup erasers have received rave reviews from YouTube vloggers and beauty mavens because they work even better than traditional makeup removers. This particular cloth is made of high-quality materials and has a nearly identical design and reviews, compared to the As Seen On TV makeup remover.

This set works the same as the classic Makeup Eraser, but is considerably more affordable. In fact, the three pieces will cost you less than just the purchase of one Makeup Eraser at Sephora, so it’s a great deal. Reviewers tend to agree that these cloths work just as well as the original Makeup Eraser and the brush cleaner tends to work just as well as the original BrushEgg, so you can’t pass up this deal.

Currently $15.99 on Amazon

And those are our recommendations for the best makeup removers. As always, be sure to check Wise Bread's Buying Calendar to learn when and how to buy just about anything!

Like this article? Pin it!

Admin settings (safe to ignore)
Custom Belimg Code: 

Disclaimer: The links and mentions on this site may be affiliate links. But they do not affect the actual opinions and recommendations of the authors.

Wise Bread is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to