Learn good financial habits from your parents. Or not.

by Philip Brewer on 8 September 2009 11 comments
Photo: Philip Brewer

One of the big advantages that children of the middle-class and wealthy have is that they grow up in a household where a huge amount of financial knowledge is embedded in its day-to-day functioning. Parents teach it, but it's also just there for the child to pick up, almost for free, like language and basic social skills. If you don't get this basic financial knowledge at home, it's possible to learn it other ways--but don't underestimate how much you need to pick up.

I talked a few days ago about getting your banking services for free. This is something that's routine for any household that's middle-class or higher, but hard for poor folks for several reasons--one of which is just that they don't know how to go about it. But that's just one example. There are so many ordinary good financial habits (like balancing your checkbook, checking your credit card statements, paying your bills on time, having an emergency fund, being careful with debt, challenging vendors who try to overcharge you, having a budget, tracking your spending, saving, investing, and living within your means) that middle-class folks pass on to their kids more or less automatically. It's hard for people who grow up in poor families to catch up.

Obviously I'm using "poor family" as shorthand. Many poor families have great household management skills to pass on to their kids. (After all, a poor family needs great household management skills lots more than a rich family does.) And there are plenty of other things besides poverty that produce the kind of generational ignorance that I'm lumping under the category of "poor family."

For example, immigrants from countries where the banking system is underdeveloped or unsound not only lack basic skills in how to use banks, they often don't even know that those skills are of value--and they're prone to pass those attitudes on to their children. Immigrants also may not speak the local language--and even people who do speak it may not read it well enough to make skillful use of things like bank fee-disclosure documents.

Still, a lot of it is just poverty--people who don't have enough money to meet the minimum balance to get free checking, people who live in poor neighborhoods where there aren't any banks (but are plenty of check-cashing and payday loan places), people who have no financial cushion against small glitches turning into major financial catastrophes.  Growing up in such a household makes it tough to learn ordinary good financial habits.

In a middle-class household, the basics of middle-class financial life are being taught all the time in many different ways:

Conscious instruction

Some things are specifically taught. For example, when I was about twelve my grandfather (who was a banker) took me to the bank to make my first deposit. He showed me how to fill out a deposit slip, pointed out what the different lines were for, showed me where to sign the check on the back to endorse it--and explained what endorsing it meant.

Really affluent parents tend to do more of this conscious instruction--teaching their children the proper relationship between family members and the bankers, brokers, and trust officers who deal with their finances. But middle-class parents can and should teach their kids their basics, from how to write a check to how to know when you're being cheated.

Modeling correct behavior

Some things are not so much taught as demonstrated. My parents used debt carefully. I remember that they had a car loan when I was small. When I was a bit older they got a mortgage to build a house on some land they owned, and I remember my parents holding firm when the deal almost fell through over a quarter of a percentage point.

My dad was a college professor and only drew his salary nine months out of the year. During those nine months, he made sure to save enough money (saved out of each paycheck at the credit union) to support us over the summer when he wasn't getting paychecks.

My mom balanced the checkbook every month. It wasn't her favorite household chore, but she did it every month anyway--a habit which I continued until I got married. (Now my wife balances the checkbook.)

Everything parents do while their kids are around demonstrates their values--how much they tip, whether they decide to wait until payday to make a purchase, what they do when a clerk makes an error, which expenses stay in the budget when money gets tight and which get cut.

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW

Letting kids help

I'm old enough that when I was a kid bank statements didn't come with your transactions all sorted by check number. They did, though, come with your canceled checks. So, step one of balancing your checkbook was taking the stack of canceled checks and sorting them into numerical order so that you could mark them off in your check register. When I was about middle-school age, I remember helping my mom by sorting the checks for her. (I remember it vividly, although I probably only did it a few times.)

When I was a bit older I remember paying the household bills a few times--I went through the stack of bills and wrote all the checks and gave them to my dad to sign.

As a small child I'd go grocery shopping with my mom and learned about things like comparing unit prices. I don't know that I was a lot of help, but I was there--not just watching, but participating.

Letting kids manage their own money

Small children will tend to make poor financial decisions for lots of reasons. Their arithmetic skills are still developing and they're still learning things like how to defer gratification. If they have some money of their own, they have a chance to learn this stuff when the consequences of poor decisions are reasonably small--no money for a comic book because they spent it on candy or vice versa.

It's hard to know how much to "help" children make the right choice. Part of the point is for children to feel the pangs of a foolish choice when both the sums and the stakes are small, so it's important to let them make their own mistakes. On the other hand, encouraging a child to save up a chunk of money to be spent on a something the child will enjoy for a long time can go a long way toward developing a life-time habit of thrift.

Casual conversation

Even when there's no actual instruction and when children aren't included by helping, they're still learning all the time. (Learning all the time is what children do. You can't stop it. All you can do is have modest influence on what they learn.)

If the parents are in basic accord, the children will tend to pick up their habits (modified to the extent that they thought things could have been done better). If the parents argue about money, their children still learn a bunch of stuff--that money is important enough to argue about, for one thing. But they also learn from the specific content of the argument. Are they arguing about luxuries versus necessities? Are they arguing about a higher standard of living versus saving? They learn something about each parent's perspective. And, since they have to live with the results, the lesson gets well and truly driven home.

Kids also learn from their friends, their friends' parents, older siblings, their neighbors, and anyone around who has money. They learn from watching and seeing what happens, but they learn in particular from what their parents say about what's happening. Casual comments about this neighbor's failed business or that neighbor having to depend on money from the in-laws make an impression. The kids will also soak up a certain amount of cause and effect from the sequence of events--when the family across the street loses its house in foreclosure, the kids will remember if it's the family that could somehow afford a new pool when no one else could and used to go on two fancy vacations every year.

Teaching yourself

There are lots of ways parents can do a poor job, from failing to do the actual instruction parts to modeling foolish or destructive behavior.

If your parents did a poor job, it falls to you to correct the errors and to fill the gaps. After all, you're the one who has to get by with whatever you know.

Yes, it's a daunting task to pick all this stuff up on your own--especially as an adult, where every mistake can have serious consequences for your family. The fact that it's going to be tough doesn't mean you should skip it, though. It just means that you need to apply yourself to learning all that stuff that luckier people learned when they were growing up.

If your parents did a good job, I hope you'll cut some slack for those whose parents didn't.  And, even if your parents did a great job, there's always more stuff to learn about managing your finances.

5
Average: 5 (1 vote)
Your rating: None
ShareThis

comments

11 discussions

Add New Comment

CAPTCHA
This test helps prevent automated spam submissions.
Guest's picture

Parents are the most important financial influences of our lives. From chores to allowances, it starts with them. My frugality comes from my parents for sure.

Yet, the biggest danger is when they become The Bank of Mom & Dad and spoil their kids to death. That's what I see all around, and their kids turn out to be underachieves and dependents even after college.

It's a balance.

Guest's picture

this is a nice post but you forget to touch about how society influences people particularly the young and impressionable in their spending habits and how to combat it. like for instance, i may buy a playstation 3 not because i need one but because all my friends have one and i may feel out of place and not forgetting all the advertisements. but all in all i have gained a little insight on a few things

Guest's picture
Ellen

The candy bar/comic part is funny, because when my dad was little his mother gave him enough money for either a candy bar or a comic book. He wanted both, naturally. So, he went into the store, bought the candy bar and sat there reading the comic book, which he put back on the shelf before leaving. (smart kid)

This is besides the point though.

I completely agree with the idea that parents influence their children's spending habits. My parents always gave me an allowance growing up, as well as the opportunity to earn more if I wanted to do more work. The phrase "Save your money." was often used in our household, and it taught me to be financially responsible. It is so important to teach kids to wait for gratification. Save your money, then you will be rewarded.

Guest's picture
Rosa

My family is working-class but my mom was a hobby investor for years and is very exacting about money - she still hand-balances her checkbook to the penny every month.

I remember when I was in high school she taught the young married couple next door how to do basic budgeting, balance their checkbook, how the interest on their mortgage worked...stuff they hadn't learned at home (even though they .

We need to be teaching this in our schools - how compound interest works, what "reconciling" means for financial statements, how percent off coupons work when they are on top of other discounts, how management fees affect returns on investment accounts, all that stuff - it's a combination of knowing what things are and being able to do basic math.

Philip Brewer's picture

It would be great to teach this stuff in school, especially the skills.  But even a great program of education on financial basics is a poor substitute for growing up in a household where everyone is doing all this stuff all the time.

Guest's picture
martha in mobile

I started giving my daughter an outrageously high allowance at age 3 ($2.75/week) so she could begin learning about long-term saving (50 cents/week) and charity (25 cents/week). I had to keep track of her money for her, but every week we divided her allowance into 3 little jars. Whenever she wanted to buy something (always, at age 3) I would tell her whether she could afford it or how long she would have to save up. Each Christmas, she chose a charity to which to give her accumulated charity savings (which I matched).

Fast forward 10 years: her allowance is now $6.50/week ($1 savings, 50 cents charity, $5 spending); she is very proud of her hundreds of dollars in savings; she is proud of her charitable contributions, and (best of all for me) she never asks to borrow money from me nor for me to buy her any teenphernalia. If she wants any stuff (usually something purple with glitter), she saves up for it.

Guest's picture

I think you're right about parents modeling financial behavior. You can read about it in a book, or learn of it at a seminar. but nothing has quite the impact of seeing it lived out.

Some things can be learned in a classroom setting, but others, like money management can only be learned by doing.

Guest's picture

From my own personal experiences I can testify financial habits start at home from an early age. Some parents (like my own) feel or felt like giving their kids everything is the way to show love. What happens is kids grow up without really understanding the value of money. For spoiled kids, figuring out what to do in life can be a real challenge.

For me, it was about learning "money doesn't buy happiness" and excessive debt means excessive stress. This realization is what changed me from "money driven loan officer" to "passionate financial fitness coach."

For kids growing up I think it's important first to be brought up with high self esteem and confidence knowing "you can accomplish anything you want in life" and "money is a tool, not the definition of who you are." Parents, please tell and teach your kids more about what they "can" do instead of what they "can't" do. Positive vibes go a long way!

Guest's picture
Olivia

I didn't learn money management at home, and as you mentioned, regretted the time it took to learn even simple skills on my own. As a result, our own kids are being consciously instructed. How much they take into adulthood I can't say, (their peers have a big influence), but at least they'll have fall back information. They'll have workable systems and structures to improve upon.

Guest's picture

I also remember learning about money through my parents at a young age. I was always encouraged to 'save' my money and use credit wisely. As soon as I was able to count with a one-to-one correspondence, I remember saving up my tiny allowance and happily counting $6.00.

I also remember receiving my first credit card and the fear I had about using it, this was also because of my parents. They always paid off their credit card every month.

However, somewhere down the road, I threw my parents tips about money to the side and went down the wrong path. Now that I am currently correcting my errors, I see that additional instruction was needed as I reached my late teen and early college years. I think my parents, at this point, thought my 'learning' was finished. Learning is never finished, it's lifelong and young adults need more guidance, not less.

Thanks for the post.
-Little House

Guest's picture
Matthew

I'm getting ready to move out of my parents house. They both keep their finances privet and never really helped me learn about budgets or balancing my checkbook (which I'm still trying to get the hang of). Growing up I always took the candy bar but thanks to my friends and blog posts like these I'm starting to get in good financial habits. Thanks for the tips!!